Thursday, 26 February 2015

Railway Budget - 2015

Para 4: . vicious cycle of under-investment.

Para 6 : carry a heavy burden of expectations.

Para 7 : In the next five years, our priority will be to significantly improve capacity on the existing high-density networks.


Para 10 : We have prepared a forward-looking agenda. Over the next five years, IR has to go through a transformation. We have fixed four goals for ourselves.

a) To deliver a sustained and measurable improvement in customer experience.
We are launching initiatives that will systematically address customer concerns about cleanliness,
comfort, accessibility, service quality and speed of trains.

b) To make Rail a safer means of travel.

c) To expand Bhartiya Rail’s capacity substantially and to modernise infrastructure.
Given the importance of rail travel for our citizens we will increase our daily passenger carrying capacity from 21million to 30 million. We will also increase track length by 20% from 1,14,000 km to 1,38,000 km, and we will grow our annual freight carrying capacity from 1 billion to 1.5 billion tonnes.

d) Finally, to make Bhartiya Rail financially self-sustainable.
This will mean generating large surpluses from our operations not only to service the debt needed to
fund our capacity expansion, but also to invest on an on-going basis to replace our depreciating assets. This will require material improvement in operating efficiency, tighter control over costs, greater discipline over project selection and execution, and a significant boost to Railways’ revenue generating capacity.


Para 12 : How will we achieve this? Our execution strategy will have five drivers:

a) Adopting a medium-term perspective:
Any organization must address short-term priorities without glossing over the long-term and medium-term vision. As Vinoba Bhave once said, “You will stumble if you look close to your heels and would certainly fall if you ignore the vision of the long road.” Madam Speaker, this Railway Budget is part of a trilogy of documents that chart out our vision for the future.

The first in the series is the White Paper that has been placed today for the information of the House.

The second part is today’s Budget for the year 2015-16. This will be followed by a Vision-2030 document that we intend to bring out later this year. The proposals contained in this Budget should, therefore, be seen as the beginning of a Five Year Action Plan to transform the Railways.


b) Building Partnerships:
Transforming the Railways will require us to partner with the key stakeholders.

First, consistent with the Prime Minister’s vision of cooperative federalism, we will work closely with the States to make the Railways the backbone of national connectivity. Their economies and citizens will benefit dramatically from an improved railway system. The voice of the locals will reverberate through the State Governments in the planning and execution of railway projects. They will also be able to raise financing through special purpose vehicles that we will create with them. Most of them have already expressed a keen interest to make the improvement of the Railways a joint
endeavour and a shared success.

Second, we will partner with PSUs to ensure that sufficient capacity is built to transport critical
commodities like coal, iron ore, and cement, etc., from where they are extracted or imported to where they are consumed or processed.

Third, we will partner with multilateral and bi-lateral organizations and other governments to gain access to long term financing and technology from overseas.

Finally, we will partner with the private sector to improve last mile connectivity, expand our fleet of rolling stock and modernize our station infrastructure.

Here I must mention that Rail will continue to be our precious national asset. It will continue to serve the common man. The people of India will always own Railways.

c) Leveraging additional resources:

Over the next five years, we envisage an investment of Rs. 8.5 lakh crore. A broad indicative five-year investment plan is attached as Annex 1 to the speech.

Budgetary support is the quickest and easiest option to finance the plan but the Ministry of Finance also faces challenges of competing demands although a small initial contribution to Railways can be catalytic. But the scale of our investment needs is such that it will require us to seek multiple sources of funding. We will tap other sources of finance. Multilateral development banks and pension funds have expressed keen interest in financing new investments. Their time horizon is aligned with
ours. They seek sources of predictable and recurring revenue, which we can provide through the issuance of long-term debt instruments to fund revenue generating railway projects.

d) Revamping management practices, systems, processes, and re-tooling of human resources:

To get the most out of the additional resources that we will be investing, we will need to ensure the highest standards of operational and business efficiency. I am happy to report an improvement on our financial performances in the year 2014-15 relative to what we had anticipated earlier. I propose the operating ratio for 2015-16 at 88.5% as against a targeted operating ratio of 91.8%in 2014-15 and 93.6% in 2013-14. I am pleased to state that not only will this be the best operating ratio in the last 9 years but the best after the VIth Pay Commission.

The Railways will not be able to deliver sustained improvement in operating efficiency unless changes are made to speed up decision making, tighten accountability, and improve management information systems.

Our people are our biggest asset. Even in the short term that I have held this portfolio I have seen the enthusiasm and dedication of Railway personnel across the country. For our transformation journey to succeed it will be very important to harness the talent of our employees through training and development.

e) Setting standards for Governance and Transparency:

The Railways belongs to the whole nation. Its functioning must conform to the highest standards of
governance and transparency. Indian Railways’ decisions must be fair to all our stakeholders; from our poorest customers, to our employees and our business partners. My first decision as a minister was to delegate all my tender approving powers to the level of general managers.

Transparency has many dimensions. It requires better quality of information gathering within that system and improved norms for disclosure of that information. It requires reduction of discretion and standardization of procedures. It requires accountability. Studies have shown that greater transparency and accountability are pro-poor instruments, since the relatively poor suffer more from lack of transparency. Apart from delegation of powers, I am proposing to undertake measures with a
view to bringing in transparency in the day-to-day activities benefitting the common man.



11 Major Thrusts

1. Quality of life in journeys.
2. Station Redevelopment
3. Capacity Augmentation
4. Safety
5. Technology upgradation
6. Partnerships for development
7. Improvements to Management Processes and Systems
8. Resource Mobilisation
9. Human Resources
10. Energy and sustainability
11. Transparency and Governance initiatives

Other areas :
Social initiatives
Tourism

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
11 Thrust areas:

1. Quality of life in journey :

Cleanliness:  Swatcch Rail under SBA- Swatcch rail swatcch Bharat.


  • to create a new department for keeping our stations and trains clean. 
  • Integrated cleaning will be taken up as a specialized activity, which will include engaging
  • professional agencies and also training our staff in the latest cleaning practices. 
  • Railways plan to set up ‘waste to energy’ conversion plants near major coaching terminals to dispose waste in an environment-friendly manner. 
  • One pilot plant will be set up, to begin with, followed by more plants in a phased manner.

The condition of toilet facilities in our stations and trains needs major improvement- Bio-toilets and vacuum toilets.
The quality of Indian Railways’ On-board Housekeeping Service

Help-line :Every responsive organization should have a system toaddress grievances from its valued customers.

Ticketing:  ‘Operation Five Minutes’ to ensure that a passenger travelling unreserved can purchase
a ticket within five minutes. Provision of modified ‘hotbuttons’, coin vending machines and ‘single destination teller’ windows will drastically reduce the transaction time. 

For the differently-abled travellers, a special initiative is being launched whereby they can purchase concessional etickets after one-time registration. It is also proposed to work towards developing a multi-lingual e-ticketing portal. We will move towards crediting all refunds through the banking system.

Catering: 

Leveraging technology: 

27. Hand-held terminals will now be provided to Travelling 
Ticket Examiners (TTEs), which can be used for verification 
of passengers and downloading charts. This system will help us to move towards paperless ticketing and charting and expedite finalization of refund claims apart from saving reams of paper. We are also exploring the idea of extending the facility of SMS on mobiles as a valid proof of travel for PRS tickets as well.


28. We are putting in place an integrated customer portal, which will be a single interface for the customers to access different services. Seamless navigation would be possible across different websites of Railways.
29. A centrally managed Railway Display Network is expected to be introduced in over 2,000 stations over the next two years which will aid in providing information on train arrival/departure, reservations, general and emergency messages and also any other information of interest to
citizens. This facility will promote “Digital India Campaign” and also unlock huge advertising revenue potential.

30. We propose to introduce an “SMS Alert” service to inform passengers in advance the updated arrival/departure time of trains at starting or destination stations. Similarly SMS alert would be sent 15/30 minutes in advance of arrival of the train at the destination.

Surveillance
31. For the safety of our women passengers, surveillance cameras will be provided on a pilot basis in selected mainline coaches and ladies’ compartments of suburban coaches without compromising on privacy.

Entertainment

Station facilities
34. So far, 1052 stations have been identified for upgradation of Passenger Amenities at Station under Adarsh station scheme. It is proposed to include 200 more stations under this scheme.

35. Wi-Fi at all A1 and A category stations is being provided. Further, as part of Digital India initiative, Wi - Fi will be provided at B category stations as well. 

36. Online booking of retiring rooms has already been initiated. The facility of self-operated lockers would also gradually be made available at stations. It is proposed to provide concierge services through the IRCTC at major stations for the assistance of passengers for their pick up and drop. We will also provide a facility for online booking of wheel chair on payment basis for senior citizens, patients and the differently-abled passengers through IRCTC on select stations.


Train capacity enhancement

Comfortable travel

PS : Use of CSR, MPLAD funds ; Better amenities to senior citizens, differently abled people.

2. Station Redevelopment


  • A transformed station can change the skyline of small and medium cities and bring in revenues, andbecome an incubator of local economy.
  • We want our Railway stations to be iconic structures with architecture reflecting the culture and character of the city. We invite the state governments and the local bodies to be our partners in this endeavour.
  • We propose to develop Satellite Railway terminals in major cities with the twin purpose of decongesting the city as well as providing service to passengers residing in suburbs.


3. Capacity Augmentation

Network expansion

Expansion of freight handling capacity

Improving train speed

Bullet train - High speed train and diamond quadilateral

Upgrading manufacturing capability

PS: Last mile connectivity is of priority for both freight and passenger.


4. Safety
66. We are preparing a five-year corporate safety plan by June 2015 indicating annual quantifiable targets. We will examine all pending recommendations made by High Level Safety Review Committee headed by Dr. Kakodkar Committee by April 2015.
PS: ROB, RUB

5. Technology upgradation
71. Every dynamic and thriving organization needs to innovate and re-invent its practices. In accordance with the vision of Hon’ble Prime Minister for Innovation, Technology Development and Manufacturing, we intend to set up an innovation council called “Kayakalp” for the purpose of business re-engineering and introducing a spirit of innovation in Railways.

PS: eliminate unmanned crossing.

6. Partnerships for development


77. We will revamp the existing PPP cell in the Ministry to make it more result oriented.
78. Railways have launched new Model Concession Agreements recently for many of the participative models, and guidelines for this have been issued.


7.Improvements to Management Processes and Systems

88. Madam Speaker, we have limited resources and thus must ensure that all public expenditure results in an optimal outcome. We, therefore, intend to set up a working group to modify the present system of accounting, to ensure tracking of expenditure to desired outcomes. The data on costing would be available online including costs incurred on constructing, augmenting, maintaining and operating railway lines. This would also help in undertaking post commissioning evaluation studies.

89. We also propose to have the train operations audited with a view to increasing productivity and bringing in transparency.

90. We are also proposing to expand paperless working in our material management system. In line with focus on ease of doing business, we will digitally integrate our vendors through Vendor Interface Management System to provide single window interface to vendors.


8. Resource Mobilisation
92. First, the Union government’s financial resources (gross budgetery support)are themselves over-stretched. 

Second, internal generation of resources will pick up once the Railway reforms start, GDP growth occurs and the Railways begin to attract traffic that has moved elsewhere, especially to the road transport sector. 

Third, for remunerative projects, it should be possible to generate resources through market  borrowings, routed through partnerships with Railway PSUs and IRFC.

Fourth, there are several areas where resources can be generated through PPP. 

Fifth, moving away from debt, some projects can be equity-driven, through partnerships with State governments. 

All these lead to a simple proposition. One can leverage the resources one possesses better.



9. Human Resources

(.. not complete)

Monday, 2 February 2015

MNREGA changes ?

Future tense as MGNREGA turns 10

Under the MGNREGA, employment has to be provided for a minimum 100 days and unemployment allowance if work is not made available
As the Mahatma Gandhi National Rural EmploymentGuarantee Act (MGNREGA) celebrates its 10th anniversary, questions are being raised on its existence because of an unprecedented fund squeeze, delays in wage payments, rampant corruption and a sharp drop in employment generated.

State after state in a meeting called to celebrate the 10th anniversary of the MGNREGA criticised the financial cuts, which for some like Bihar and Manipur have lead to a drop in work generated.

Under the MGNREGA, employment has to be provided for a minimum 100 days and unemployment allowance if work is not made available.

"Bihar's total dues to the Centre for the MGNREGA is around Rs 600 crore, which includes payment for work done for which wages have not been paid, but there has been no positive response from the Centre so far," Nitish Mishra, the state's rural development minister, told Business Standard.

He said Bihar had been released funds far less than required for the MGNREGA in 2014-15, which had led to a drop in employment generated.

Assam's Minister for Rural Development Raqibul Hussain felt the MGNREGA's stringent conditions made it difficult for North-Eastern states to receive the full benefits of the scheme.

"The number of person days per households has come down from 68 a few years ago to just 10 in 2014-15, which is a reflection of the funds crunch we are facing," said Manipur's Rural Development Minister Francis Ngajokpa.

Unofficial estimates show funds released for the MGNREGA till September 2014 were around Rs 10,000 crore less than in the same period of the previous year.
Description: http://bsmedia.business-standard.com/_media/bs/img/article/2015-02/03/full/1422905282-4072.jpgAgainst the Rs 5,296.19 crore sanctioned for Andhra Pradesh, Rs 2,500 crore had been released till December. The state has spent more than the released amount. Its outstanding dues on January 1, 2015, were Rs 1,397 crore.

The squeeze is being felt even in states ruled by the Bharatiya Janata Party. Chhattisgarh's Rural Development Minister Ajay Chandrakar pointed to the difficulty in implementing electronic transfer of wages, suggested as a measure to reduce delays. He said of the 146 blocks in the state 86 were in Naxal-dominated areas, where the banking network was poor and implementing electronic transfers difficult.

Union Rural Development Minister Chaudhury Birender Singh, however, said of the Rs 34,000 crore budgeted for the MGNREGA, around Rs 27,000 crore had been released and the rest would also be allocated after adjusting the unspent amount.

"Timely payment under the MGNREGA is essential as it is a demand-driven scheme, but you all should also understand that the rural development ministry is not the only one involved in this," Singh said. He added he would request the finance ministry for more funds for an improved version of the scheme where skill development was a big component.

"The rising liability under the MGNREGA and months of pending wages are virtually killing the Act. According to government records, 75 per cent of people are not being paid wages on time," social activist Nikhil Dey said at a press conference later in the day. He said if the government wanted to do away with the MGNREGA, it should do so openly.

"It is the typical Gujarat model of growth, where you slowly close down entitlement schemes in the name of development," said Jayati Ghosh, professor of economics at Jawaharlal Nehru University.

NDA planned to amend, restrict rural job Act

Limits funds to states under the scheme and still looking to reduce labour budget ratios

The National Democratic Alliance (NDA) government had begun work on amending the Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Act (MGNREGA), restricting the coverage to a few backward districts, leaving out large portions of Punjab, Haryana, Maharashtra, Gujarat, Tamil Nadu and Kerala from its ambit. The plan was eventually shelved after protests and a debate in Parliament in December.

This is disclosed in internal notes of the ministry revealed through a Right to Information application. The notes also disclose disquiet in the ministry over the proposal to change the ratio in the Budget provided for manual labour and material from 60:40 to 51:49 at the district level. The ministry officials noted in August 2014 that the decision would adversely impact five crore households and result in the employment provided to the poor coming down by 136 crore persondays. The officials also noted that while the move was 'technically possible', it ran contrary to the spirit of the law, which was meant to create employment opportunities for unskilled workers.

The officials pointed out that hiking the material component could also have an impact on the budgetary resources, as then almost 50 per cent of the total 2014-15 Budget will go for material, leaving very little for wages, necessitating an additional fund infusion of around Rs 20,000 crore in 2014-15 if the work provided under the law were to be maintained at the same level.

This proposal is still alive in the ministry, sources said. The proposal to amend the law to restrict it to backward districts only, which has now been put to rest, was originally mooted by the rural development ministry to the Prime Minister's Office (PMO) in June 2014. The ministry note reads, "The Act needs to be amended through Parliament to enable its coverage only in backward districts/blocks." The 
PMO asked the ministry to examine the possibility and the then Rural Development Minister Nitin Gadkari too approved of such a move. But, in August, the PMO held another meeting, after many activists and economists protested. In the meeting, it was decided to bury the decision, said sources. Now, within the ambit of the existing law, a special focus has been put on the backward districts but other districts cannot be outright denied monies under the scheme.

But a fund crunch imposed by the Centre and much-delayed release of these, began to squeeze
MGNREGA anyway by then, documents accessed through RTI show. The labour budget (the estimation done at the beginning of the year of work to be provided under the law) was approved for 227 crore persondays. This worked out to more than Rs 60,000 crore. But the budgetary allocation (then under UPA government) was limited to Rs 34,000 crore.

Out of this, in the first tranche at the beginning of the financial year, only Rs 7,309 was released to states - just enough to pay the pending wages from previous year. In July 2014, the rural development ministry created another rule that put a cap on the funds the Centre would give to the states each quarter. This turned the scheme from a demand-driven one to one controlled by central government's purse strings. Then, in the mid-year revision of the Budget brought the allocation to the scheme has now been brought down from Rs 34,000 crore to Rs 31,000 crore.

The delay in funds from Centre made several states, including those under BJP rule, write to the Centre in January, documents show. These included, Chhattisgarh, Telangana, Bihar, Jharkhand and West Bengal. They noted that restrictions on funds were preventing them from offering work to the poor under the scheme.



-- Business standard 03 feeb 2015

Sunday, 1 February 2015

e-commerce and Regulation

E-tail regulation might be split among 9 bodies

Each could handle a designated area, says note by consumer affairs ministry
To get over the ambiguity on regulation of the burgeoning e-commerce business, a note prepared for a committee of secretaries (COS) has designated nine departments in the government with specific areas and issues in the sector to handle and oversee.

E-commerce has become the fastest growing business in the country, coupled with blockbuster funding from domestic and foreign investors. It has also faced allegations of tax evasion and rule-breaking by major e-tailers.
The draft note, prepared by the ministry of consumer affairs, earmarks responsibility to each ministry or department on the area of regulation they would oversee for e-commerce companies.
1.      Thus, taxation-related issues will be regulated by the department of revenue.
2.      The Reserve Bank of India will monitor only issues involving foreign exchange and banking issues.
3.      The ministry of corporate affairs would look into all allegations and complaints about predatory pricing, unfair trade practice and criminal fraud.
SUPERVISING E-COMMERCE
·         Taxation could be looked after by the department of revenue.
·         RBI to monitor foreign exchange and banking issues
·         Consumer grievances and consumer protection to be under the ministry of consumer affairs

Many traditional retailers and consumer goods companies have complained that online retailers are involved in predatory pricing, selling below cost of acquisition to destroy their business.

The lack of licensing, the draft note argues, has made monitoring and supervision of e-retailing difficult.

4.      Issues regarding foreign direct investment (FDI) and policy on e-commerce would be under the ministry of commerce, department of industrial policy and promotion. Amazon.com, for one, has been lobbying for the relaxation of FDI norms for its business to consumer line. Presently, no FDI is allowed here in retail (B2C) but allowed in wholesale (B2B).

5.      Issues of data protection and cyber security would be handled by department of electronics and information technology. There has been a move by the government to ask e-retailers to set up data centres in the country, citing loss of business as most of these are located outside India.

6.      Advertising and guidelines would be handled by the ministry of information & broadcasting. Especially as e-commerce companies have become one of the largest advertisers, on television, print and the net, and are known for their aggressive stance. It has been observed that many of the rules governing the print and broadcasting business cannot be applied on internet advertising because of the relative anonynomity of the business.

7.      The ministry of consumer affairs has contended the operations of e-commerce are too diverse and complex to be under the purview of one ministry or department. Therefore, what is needed is clear demarcation of related activities, to be handled by different departments or ministries.

8.       The ministry says it would oversee all issues regarding consumer grievances and consumer protection. However, there is need for clarity in defining 'internal trade', especially with regard to e-commerce activities to be handled by department of consumer affairs.
9.       Database by statistics departments.

E-commerce in India was valued at $3 billion in 2014 and is expected to swell to $15 billion in two years.

Flipkart had fuelled a controversy when it unveiled a 'Big Billion Day' sale late last year, leading to complaints from consumers and allegations of predatory pricing. This led to traditional retailers lobbying against the online ones.

American giant Amazon has been facing scrutiny from state tax departments over the warehouses that store products from various sellers listed on it. Recently, reports surfaced of Flipkart and Amazon also being targeted for alleged tax evasion in Kerala.


-from business standard




Govt mulling regulatory regime for e-commerce

During any probe on online frauds, the government will be troubled by problems in accessing data on servers and data centres situated overseas. (Illustration: Shyam)
In a bid to effectively regulate the country’s e-commerce market, which has more than tripled in the last 4-5 years, the government is considering a regime where there will be a clear demarcation of the sector’s activities to be handled by different ministries and regulators.
Pointing out that e-commerce activities are very complex and diverse to be kept under the jurisdiction of a single department or ministry, the department of consumer affairs has moved a note for the consideration of the committee of secretaries (CoS) and sought approval for a proposal for clear allocation of business rules with respect to the sector.
Currently, there is no single law in the country to regulate, monitor and supervise e-commerce. Also, what is making monitoring a very difficult task is the lack of  a mechanism of registration/licencing of online retailers, sources said.
·         Besides, the government has taken note of online retailers cleverly taking undue advantage  by operating out of low tax regions, they said.
·         During any probe on online frauds, the government will be troubled by problems in accessing data on servers and data centres situated overseas, they said.
·         They added that all such issues necessitate clarity and formalisation in how different government departments handle e-commerce activities.

According to the consumer affairs department’s proposal,
1.      the department of revenue will handle taxation related issues,
2.      the Reserve Bank of India should look into banking and foreign exchange issues.
3.      The consumer protection issues will be taken care of by the consumer affairs department,
4.      foreign investment and trade policy will be under the purview of the commerce and industry ministry.
5.      The ministry of IT and telecom will handle data protection, cyber security and issues related to registration of server and websites,
6.      competition policy related matters will fall within the corporate affairs ministry’s jurisdiction.
7.      Criminal frauds will be looked into by the finance, corporate and home ministries.
8.      A database on the sector will be maintained by the statistics department,
9.      the information and broadcasting ministry will take care of advertising norms and related matters.
This kind of a system is needed in the future because most of the complaints related to the sector are being referred to the consumer affairs department on the contention that since the department looks into ‘internal trade’ matters, it should handle e-commerce matters, too, as such activities also constitute ‘internal trade’.

Existing shortcomings/ complaints:
1.      However, the consumer affairs department has asked for more clarity in the definition of ‘internal trade’. The department said though it can take care of consumer protection issues and grievances, e-commerce also has several other issues including tax evasion, online frauds, predatory business practices, data privacy/cyber security and FDI.

2.      On other problems related to e-commerce, the department said since there is no list of genuine/licensed online sellers, consumers do not have any mechanism to distinguish between genuine and fraudulent e-commerce players.
3.      Besides, many of the sellers also do not provide proper contact information, the department said.
4.      Also, consumers have been confused by different operating procedures followed by online traders for placing orders and purchasing, it said.
5.      The department added there are several complaints related to delivery of services and products as well as in cancelling orders and getting refunds for returned items.
6.      The department said small and medium enterprises (SMEs) with very limited resources are troubled by multiplicity of rules and regulations of e-commerce, and therefore are not able to make use of business opportunities.

- from Financial Express

E-commerce to be policed by up to nine government agencies including RBI, Home Ministry, Finance Ministry

NEW DELHI: A panel of top central government bureaucrats is set to soon consider a proposal for potentially extensive regulation of the country's ecommerce industry, a move certain to raise the hackles of the sector whose furious pace of growth has alarmed traditional businesses and spawned calls for greater oversight of their business practices.

The department of consumer affairs has mooted the proposal for final consideration of the highpowered committee of secretaries (CoS) that could bring ecommerce under the purview of up to nine government agencies and regulatory bodies, including
 RBI, home ministry, the department of revenue in the finance ministry, and ministry of corporate affairs.

All ministries concerned have been asked to give their inputs on the issue before it is taken up by the committee of secretaries, widely regarded as the most important decisionmaking body after the
 Union Cabinet.

At present, most complaints about the ecommerce sector are referred to the department of consumer affairs. However, this department argues in a draft note prepared for the panel that the ecommerce sector's operations were too complex to be under the purview of any single ministry and therefore "a clear demarcation of the activities of ecommerce should be handled by different departments".

The note also points out that the "complexity" and the "diversity" of ecommerce has created confusion about appropriate regulation, and the government therefore needs to demarcate the jurisdiction of various departments.

"The emergence of ecommerce has given rise to the need for specific guidelines of monitoring and regulation of the industry. However, at present issues linked to ecommerce do not come under the purview of a single legislation or department/ministry," the note added. The note, however, acknowledges that ecommerce firms have shown significant growth because of several advantages they offered consumers — notably easy and direct accessibility of goods across boundaries, wide and varied choices, affordable prices and savings. Experts decried the move to bring the sector under a regulatory umbrella.

"There are enough rules, the industry doesn't need any new rules. If the government has consumer protection in mind, we welcome steps which would reduce fraud across retail — both online and offline," said
 Arvind Singhal, chairman of retail consultancy Technopak.

"Online trade is a modern day reality and the government cannot put the genie back in the bottle. The beauty of ecommerce trade is the very fact that it eases buying and selling, and cuts time. The moment you push it under the heavy weight of regulations, they will only rob the ecommerce industry of its advantages over other forms of retail trade," Singhal said, adding that if the new rules were being made only at the behest of the traditional retailers, India's reputation would suffer in the minds of global investors.

The surging popularity of ecommerce among shoppers and the heady sales growth enjoyed by top players such as Flipkart, Amazon and
 Snapdeal has got traditional retailers to complain to the government about what they claim are unfair business practices employed by the online lot.

Traditional retailers have complained their online counterparts sell goods below cost and the predatory pricing disrupts their businesses.

India's ecommerce sector, according to government estimates, is expected to
 touch Rs 50,400 crore in sales by 2015-16 excluding tickets and online sales, up from around Rs 13,900 crore in 2012-13 — an annual growth clip of 50-55%. A recent report by Japanese bank Nomura forecast Indian ecommerce to be worth $43 billion in five years, of which nearly $23 billion will come from online retail. The principal protagonists in the sector have raised copious amounts of cash in 2014 — Flipkart, for instance, received about $1.9 billion in funding last year and saw its valuation leap nearly ten-fold in the space of ten months to $11 billion.
Despite the heady growth, the ecommerce sector is still just 0.5% of the overall retail industry, indicating the large headroom it has to grow.

·         The consumer affairs department's note highlighted that government agencies were increasingly complaining about issues in accessing data on servers or data centres of online retailers while investigating online fraud and also about the lack of mechanism for registration of online retailers due to which monitoring and supervision of the industry was very difficult.
·         Certain wings of the government also felt that due to the inherent anonymity and dynamic nature of the Internet, advertising laws and mechanisms that apply to print and electronic media platforms do not work well when it came to the ecommerce sector.


Various trade associations, consumer fora as well as members of Parliament have raised concerns about the functioning of ecommerce websites.

Traditional retailers have complained that the growth of online retail in the absence of specified regulations or permissions from local and state authorities was threatening their survival and thereby jeopardising the employment of 3.3 crore people.

The move to explore greater regulation in India comes at a time neighbouring China, home to the world's biggest ecommerce firm Alibaba Group, has also cracked down on the sector.

Earlier this week, the Chinese State Administration for Industry and Commerce accused Alibaba's consumer ecommerce platform Taobao of allowing unauthorised stores to sell counterfeit goods, due to what they termed as widespread bribery between merchants and Taobao employees.

- from Economic times